What the comparison supports
The missing checks affected the conclusions.
Carbon read a summary and left its network diagnosis unverified. Argon answered for another platform. Hydrogen identified the hardware and then asked the user for a specification it could have looked up. Opus’s extra work produced a concrete candidate and a clear remaining test.
One task, one completed answer per model.
All four successful sessions used the same prompt, CLI version, working directory and High effort. The counts were derived from individual transcript events. Output totals include tool-generating responses and report writing. A recorded reasoning field indicates that the CLI received metadata. Providers expose it differently.
These sessions establish how four answers were researched. They cannot establish a model-wide regression, its cause, or whether the proposed deployment would work.